Submit The issue is complex God Bless those who serve in the American military. That they answered a call when they did not have to makes them more honorable than anyone who would be drafted.
Next to me was Jim, another British army officer, and Captain Dimitris, who was escorting us during our observer-attachment to the Hellenic army. As we waited for the target convoy to pass, we chatted in whispers. The subject of Iraq came round.
I had done my tour a year or so before; Jim was shortly to deploy. At the time, I put it down to another instance of the mild culture shock we were mostly enjoying. The day before, a private had come to our bivouac and politely enquired where in Britain we were based.
In Catterick, in Yorkshire, we answered.
The private nodded and rested his arms across his machine-gun. He explained in wistful, excellent English that he was more familiar with the south.
He had decided to come back to Greece and get his military service out of the way while he sorted out funding for his PhD. In his sentiments and situation, that private was not unusual. A number of the Greek grunts had at least a college degree and spoke pretty good English.
Their interest in politics and international affairs was also correspondingly higher than Jim and I were used to from the men under our command. From our hosting officers, I was also becoming aware how a deployment to Iraq was viewed with a mixture of curiosity and embarrassment.
Every mother would need to know why.
Readers might be feeling a familiar sense of despair: Our governments order it, and it just happens. For the ancient Athenians, a non-negotiable prerequisite for citizenship was the completion of compulsory military service and availability in the reserves. To hold public office and voting rights, you had to have skin in the game: In short, Athenian citizens could not afford not to care about their foreign policy.
Nowadays, the mere suggestion that developed western nations should revive compulsory military service is liable to strike us as absurd, if not unethical. Neither is it an enticing prospect to be posted hundreds of miles from home to a remote outpost, where one can expect a tedious round of guard duty, potato-peeling and toilet-mopping, leavened by a occasional training exercise and border patrols in the cold and heat.
In the US presidential election, Richard Nixon was counting on this sense of outraged individuality when he campaigned to repeal the draft. He reasoned that the middle-class white students protesting against the Vietnam War were doing so mainly out of self-interest.Nov 07, · Veterans Day: With numbers dwindling, should military or civilian service be required?
On Veterans Day, some wonder if national service — military or civilian — should be expected of all. Mandatory military service or military conscription is a strategy used by countries to build a large and powerful military ready to be deployed in times of war or when the need to .
Yes, all men should be required to serve, but by default they should be enlisted into the reserves.
Active Duty requires commitment; It's four years (minimum) of getting messed with, treated like a child, and mad for a variety of other reasons, all the while being the last to TOLD when you're deploying.
Feb 13, · Military services shouldn’t be Mandatory. military service should not be mandatory. It’s difficult to build a strong army via mandatory military service. First of all, the army that is built by mandatory service can’t choose the right person to hire, so it chooses someone who isn’t ready to serve in the military field.
If our own apathy troubles us, as it should, it is perhaps our own fault for letting slip one of the core tenets of the world's first democracy. For the ancient Athenians, a non-negotiable prerequisite for citizenship was the completion of compulsory military service and availability in the reserves.
- Military service in the United States should be compulsory (required) because it will provide economic and social benefits to those people who are serving as well as create a benefit for the general public as well as nation as a whole.